The Constitutional Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act of 2025 (HR 38) would allow a person eligible to carry a concealed handgun in their home state to also do so in other states. [1] For example, someone from Texas, where permits are not required to carry, could carry a concealed handgun in Maryland without meeting Maryland’s permit requirements. As of February 2025, twenty-nine states have “constitutional carry or permitless carry laws,” [2] but those laws apply only within their own borders. Ranking Member of the House Judiciary Committee Jamie Raskin dissented, warning that the bill would “require states to accept the standards set by the most lenient states, some of which have no standards at all.” [3]
While HR 38 covers school grounds, the zones around them are not included. The power Congress has to require reciprocity is weakest around schools, both because schools are areas the Supreme Court has recognized as traditionally governed by the states and because school zones are plausibly sensitive places the Second Amendment does not protect. Congress must therefore make clear that HR 38 will not override state school-zone laws. The Gun-Free School Zones Act (GFSZA) makes it a federal crime to carry a firearm “within a distance of 1,000 feet from the grounds of a public, parochial or private school,” [4] unless the carrier holds a license from the state where the school is located. Under HR 38, however, visitors would “not be subject to the prohibitions of section 922(q),” [5] the GFSZA’s school-zone ban, even where a local resident without that state’s license would still be breaking federal law. HR 38 does preserve state laws restricting guns on “any State or local government property, installation, building, or base,” [6] and the committee report confirms visitors remain “subject to state laws prohibiting firearm possession on school grounds.” [7] But neither provision clearly covers the 1,000 feet around schools that the GFSZA protects today, including sidewalks, streets, and bus stops where students arrive and leave. Even the committee’s dissenting members read the bill this way, warning that it “specifically allows” visitors to carry “in a gun-free school zone.” [8]
The concept of HR 38 is not new: a 2017 version passed the House, 231 to 198, but stalled in the Senate, preventing it from becoming a law. [9] The 2025 version cleared the House Judiciary Committee and has awaited a full House vote since October 2025. [10] Supporters argue that it protects “the ability to travel freely between states without worrying about conflicting state codes.” [11] The evidence complicates that argument: a study by Stanford Law School professor John J. Donohue III and his coauthors, Abhay Aneja and Kyle D. Weber, found that right-to-carry laws are correlated with a 13 to 15 percent increase in violent crime ten years after enactment. [12] Supporters also compare carrying a gun across state lines to driving a car across them, but every state requires drivers to pass written and road tests, while carry permit requirements “vary widely from state to state, with most not requiring live-fire training.” [13] Opponents argue that the bill would “supplant the judgment, authority, and autonomy of each state.” [14] HR 38 also impacts police, who would be expected to apply all fifty states’ laws in real time. [15] The Fraternal Order of Police warned that the bill would limit officers’ ability to arrest or detain someone for gun violations, including carrying in school zones. [16]
While federal law has long regulated guns near schools and preserved states’ power to protect their own school zones, HR 38 would override those protections for visitors. Congress’s power to regulate guns around schools has been tested before. One case that outlined the limits of such power is United States v. Lopez, [17] in which high schooler Alfonso Lopez Jr was federally charged with carrying a concealed handgun into his school. [18] The Court struck down the 1990 version of the GFSZA, holding that Congress could not base it on the Commerce Clause, since possessing a gun in a school zone is “in no sense an economic activity,” [19] and that education is among the areas where states “historically have been sovereign.” [20] Congress responded in 1996 by limiting the ban to a firearm that has “moved in or that otherwise affects interstate or foreign commerce.” [21] HR 38 relies on the same link: its constitutional authority statement cites only the Commerce Clause, [22] even though it names its subject as the “second amendment,” likely because, as Hayley Lawrence, Executive Director of the Center for Firearms Law at Duke University School of Law, explained, “everything Congress does in terms of regulation is at least somewhat related to the commerce clause.” [23] Yet the acts differ in two key ways. First, HR 38 contradicts Congress’s own judgment about school safety. Unlike HR 38, the GFSZA includes congressional findings that violent crime in school zones “has resulted in a decline in the quality of education,” and that this decline has “an adverse impact on interstate commerce.” [24] HR 38 disregards that judgment: a visitor could carry a concealed handgun within 1,000 feet of a school without whatever permit, training, or background check the host state requires of its own residents. In HR 38, Congress never acknowledges its earlier concerns about school safety. Second, the two laws treat state power in opposite ways. The GFSZA provides that “nothing in this subsection shall be construed as preempting or preventing a State or local government from enacting a statute establishing gun free school zones.” [25] The GFSZA’s licensing exception even defers to the state where the school is located. [26] HR 38, by contrast, lets visitors carry “notwithstanding any provision of the law of any State.” [27] Concurring in Lopez, Justice Kennedy urged courts to ask “whether the exercise of national power seeks to intrude upon an area of traditional state concern,” noting that “it is well established that education is a traditional concern of the States.” [28] HR 38 fails that test more clearly than any version of the GFSZA: rather than layering a federal rule onto state school-zone laws, it overrides them, moving the line Lopez drew to keep areas like education and local safety with the states.
If the Commerce Clause cannot support HR 38, supporters may instead turn to the Second Amendment, which the bill names as its subject. The committee report relies on District of Columbia v. Heller, [29] McDonald v. City of Chicago, [30] and New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. [31] But Heller and Bruen confirm the right’s limits in “sensitive places such as schools and government buildings.” [32] They name schools, not school zones, so the key question is whether school zones count. There is a strong reason to think they do. Experts like Lawrence read “schools” to include school zones. [33] Similarly, William & Mary Law School professor Timothy Zick lists bans on carrying near schools among permissible regulations, while noting the scope of “schools” remains unresolved. [34] History points the same way: in 1879, Senate Republicans, many of whom had voted for the Fourteenth Amendment, proposed banning guns within a mile of polling places, suggesting they saw buffer zones around sensitive places as consistent with the right. [35] The Second Amendment forbids infringing the “right of the people to keep and bear arms”; it does not grant Congress power. [36] Instead, supporters would have to rely on Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment, which lets Congress “enforce” the right McDonald applied to the states through the Due Process Clause. [37] However, in City of Boerne v. Flores, [38] the Court held that “Congress does not enforce a constitutional right by changing what the right is.” [39] Under HR 38, state school-zone laws may be overridden for visitors in the name of protecting gun rights; here, Congress is deciding that state school-zone laws violate a right the Court admits is not being violated. At schools, there is nothing to enforce. Whether the right reaches zones around them remains an open question, and Boerne suggests it is one for the courts, not Congress, to answer. [40] Without explicit protection for school zones, resting HR 38 on the Second Amendment is unstable, as school zones are likely among the sensitive places the right does not protect.
HR 38 should expressly preserve state school-zone laws by adding school zones to the list of state laws it already protects in subsection (b) [41]. The new provision would read: “(3) prohibit or restrict the possession of firearms in a school zone, as defined in section 921(a)(26).” This single addition would ensure state school-zone laws apply to visitors. While Congress can choose to exempt visitors from its own federal ban, [42] even if doing so contradicts its own findings, it should not strip states of their own bans. Whatever power Congress has to mandate reciprocity is at its weakest around schools, so any reciprocity law must explicitly preserve state school-zone laws.
Edited by Ameera Mehan
Endnotes
[1] HR 38, 119th Cong, 1st Sess § 2(a) (Jan 3, 2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/38/text (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[2] HR Rep No 119-337, 119th Cong, 1st Sess 5 (2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/committee-report/119th-congress/house-report/337/1 (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[3] Ibid, 17.
[4] 18 USC §§ 921(a)(26), 922(q)(2)(A), (B)(ii) (2024), online at https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-120/t18/s922/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[5] HR 38, 119th Cong, 1st Sess § 2(a) (Jan 3, 2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/38/text (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[6] Ibid.
[7] HR Rep No 119-337, 119th Cong, 1st Sess 15 (2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/committee-report/119th-congress/house-report/337/1 (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[8] Ibid, 19 (dissenting views).
[9] Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act of 2017, HR 38, 115th Cong, 1st Sess (Jan 3, 2017), in 163 Cong Rec H 9685 (daily ed Dec 6, 2017), online at https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/38/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[10] HR Rep No 119-337, 119th Cong, 1st Sess 1, 7 (2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/committee-report/119th-congress/house-report/337/1 (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[11] Ibid, 6.
[12] John J. Donohue III, Abhay Aneja, and Kyle D. Weber, “Right-to-Carry Laws and Violent Crime: A Comprehensive Assessment Using Panel Data and a State-Level Synthetic Controls Analysis,” 16 Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 198, 198 (2019), online at https://law.stanford.edu/publications/right-to-carry-laws-and-violent-crime-a-comprehensive-assessment-using-panel-data-and-a-state-level-synthetic-controls-analysis/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[13] Chip Brownlee, “What Would ‘Concealed Carry Reciprocity’ Mean for States With Tighter Gun Laws?,” The Trace (Dec 2, 2025), online at https://www.thetrace.org/2025/12/concealed-carry-reciprocity-gun-law/ (visited Oct 12, 2026).
[14] HR Rep No 119-337, 119th Cong, 1st Sess 17 (2025) (dissenting views), online at https://www.congress.gov/committee-report/119th-congress/house-report/337/1 (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[15] Ibid, 20 (dissenting views).
[16] Brownlee, “What Would ‘Concealed Carry Reciprocity’ Mean for States With Tighter Gun Laws?,” The Trace (Dec 2, 2025), online at https://www.thetrace.org/2025/12/concealed-carry-reciprocity-gun-law/ (visited Oct 12, 2026), quoting Fraternal Order of Police and International Association of Chiefs of Police.
[17] 514 US 549 (1995), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/514/549/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[18] Ibid, 551.
[19] Ibid, 567.
[20] Ibid, 564.
[21] 18 USC § 922(q)(2)(A) (2024), online at https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-120/t18/s922/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[22] 171 Cong Rec H 36 (daily ed Jan 3, 2025) (statement of Representative Richard Hudson).
[23] Interview with Hayley Lawrence, Executive Director, Center for Firearms Law, Duke University School of Law (Oct 27, 2026).
[24] 18 USC § 922(q)(1)(F)–(G) (2024), online at https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-120/t18/s922/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[25] 18 USC § 922(q)(4) (2024), online at https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-120/t18/s922/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[26] 18 USC § 922(q)(2)(B)(ii) (2024), online at https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-120/t18/s922/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[27] HR 38, 119th Cong, 1st Sess § 2(a) (Jan 3, 2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/38/text (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[28] United States v. Lopez, 514 US 549, 580 (1995) (Kennedy, concurring), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/514/549/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[29] 554 US 570 (2008), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[30] 561 US 742 (2010), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/561/742/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[31] 597 US 1 (2022), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/597/20-843/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[32] District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 US 570, 626 (2008), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/ (visited Oct 30, 2026); New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, 597 US 1, 30 (2022), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/597/20-843/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[33] Lawrence interview.
[34] Timothy Zick, “Firearms and Fora: Constructing Public Carry Doctrine,” 106 Boston University Law Review 365, 424, 431 (2026), online at https://www.bu.edu/bulawreview/files/2026/06/ZICK.pdf (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[35] Mark Anthony Frassetto, “Firearms in Sensitive Places and the Military Appropriations Crisis of 1879,” Gonzaga Law Review (forthcoming 2026) (manuscript at 8, 10–11), online at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5348011 (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[36] US Const Amend II, online at https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-2/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[37] US Const Amend XIV, §§ 1, 5, online at https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-14/ (visited Oct 30, 2026); McDonald v. City of Chicago, 561 US 742, 791 (2010), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/561/742/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[38] 521 US 507 (1997), online at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/521/507/ (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[39] Ibid, 519.
[40] Ibid.
[41] HR 38, 119th Cong, 1st Sess § 2(a) (Jan 3, 2025), online at https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/38/text (visited Oct 30, 2026).
[42] Ibid.