Bridging the Gap: Caregiver-Mediated Access to Medicaid under the ADA

Medicaid eligibility is notoriously complex. Within disability law, formal eligibility for Medicaid coverage is not the same as meaningful access, and caregiver success does not signify that the state itself provides proper support. As a result, many otherwise eligible disabled dependents fall through its cracks and lose coverage. Those who successfully navigate the Medicaid system to renew eligibility for their children represent an overcoming of immense barriers, creating an illusion of a functioning administrative process. In some cases, disabled and vulnerable individuals lose access to necessary healthcare and insurance coverage, even if they do not have the ability to influence the process–as that is the responsibility of their parents or legal guardians. Access to crucial medicine and resources is directly inhibited for no reason other than misfiled paperwork. For example, when faced with such procedural issues, many adults defer office-based care until they gain coverage once again, if they do. [1] Therefore, Medicaid agencies should evaluate caregiver-mediated administrative barriers as part of their obligation to provide meaningful access under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). 

During the unwinding of the COVID-19 public health emergency’s continuous enrollment protections, states resumed regular eligibility redeterminations and millions of beneficiaries lost coverage. [2] However, many were disenrolled for procedural reasons, including failures to return requested information. From March to September of 2023, 6.6 million people disenrolled from Medicaid/Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) coverage due to administrative issues, which equates to 72 percent of total disenrolled in that unwinding period. [3] This is an example of Medicaid procedural churn, which occurs when beneficiaries lose coverage because an eligibility determination cannot be completed, rather than because the state has established that they are not eligible. For beneficiaries with disabilities, the consequences of such minor mistakes are often dire: temporary loss of insurance as well as disrupted access to medications, treatment, and ongoing medical care. In many cases, the beneficiary that loses coverage is not at fault, as parents or legal guardians must complete it on their behalf. Such beneficiaries are those who cannot make legal decisions or complete the paperwork for themselves: minors, seniors, individuals with intellectual or developmental disabilities, and others. 

The renewal process that facilitates procedural churn imposes unnecessary strain on caregivers who navigate the renewal process on behalf of disabled beneficiaries. For families of disabled beneficiaries, completing a renewal can involve gathering medical and financial documentation, monitoring correspondence, coordinating with providers, and responding to deadlines. When a notice is missed or documentation is not submitted correctly, the consequences fall on the beneficiary, even when a parent or guardian has made substantial efforts to preserve coverage. Caregivers serve as a practical link between a beneficiary and the state agency. Therefore, a caregivers’ ability to relay benefits from the agency to the beneficiary exposes a potential gap between formal eligibility and its applicability. Given that all Medicaid claims for children are made by parents or guardians, simply hoping that a caregiver puts forth such effort is not a sustainable way to ensure access to benefits. The unsustainability of this model only increases when one considers adults who rely on the actions of legal guardians. Disability-access protections should more explicitly account for caregiver-mediated access to public benefits. 

Disability-related barriers to renewal procedures are in clear violation of  Title II of the ADA. Title II of the ADA provides that “no qualified individual with a disability shall, by reason of such disability, be excluded from participation in or be denied the benefits of the services, programs, or activities of a public entity, or be subjected to discrimination by any such entity.”  [4] State Medicaid agencies fall within the public entities covered by Title II, meaning they should be held responsible to this standard. Currently, Title II protections apply when a barrier related to someone’s disability makes it difficult to access their own benefits or renew their eligibility, but does not adequately address this caregiver gap.

Within the ADA, there are numerous additional regulations that provide protections to ensure disabled individuals seeking coverage can access benefits. Under 42 C.F.R § 435.916, states must follow prescribed renewal procedures, such as checking available information, before requiring beneficiaries to provide additional documentation. [5] Additionally, Section 35.130 (b)(7) generally requires reasonable modifications to policies, practices, or procedures when necessary to avoid disability discrimination, subject to applicable limitations. [6] In other words, a renewal process is illegal if an agency fails to accommodate an individual’s inability to complete something due to a disability. An agency must provide the necessary modifications for someone with a disability when a standard submission procedure is difficult or inaccessible for them. For example, state agencies cannot rely on communications a beneficiary cannot access due to their disability. Where a particular procedure creates a disability-related barrier, the ADA requires a reasonable modification rather than rigid adherence to a standard process. 

In reality, such flexibility is very limited. The ADA does not require modification if the person filling out the paperwork, such as a parent or guardian, does not have a qualifying disability themselves. A child’s access to benefits is assumed through their guardian, yet the guardianship means dependents are unable to gain support in the process through procedural modifications. There is no explicit legal requirement for such accommodations from state agencies.

Such accommodations, however, would be incredibly beneficial for caregivers struggling to navigate the system on behalf of their dependents. A caregiver is required to expend substantial time and effort overcoming administrative obstacles to preserve a child’s coverage. Where the parent succeeds, that effort may conceal deficiencies or inconsistencies in the state’s procedures. When the parent does not, the beneficiary may bear the consequences through an interruption in coverage, despite remaining substantively eligible. A caregiver’s ability to compensate for an inaccessible administrative process does not mean the state has provided the beneficiary meaningful access.

There is existing precedent from the United States Supreme Court considering the importance of such nuance. In Alexander v. Choate, The Supreme Court considered a challenge under § 504 of the Rehabilitation Act to Tennessee’s limit on the number of Medicaid-covered hospital days. [7] In a unanimous decision, the Court upheld the coverage limit that was challenged; the opinion claims that although disability-discrimination law must provide individuals with disabilities “meaningful access” to public programs, it does not require every program to produce identical outcomes. This case neither establishes that procedural disenrollment violates disability law, nor does it directly concern the ADA. However, it provides precedent on how to evaluate whether a program’s design or administration prevents people with disabilities from accessing its benefits. Regarding the guiding tension between individual discrimination and administrative burden, Justice Marshall writes, “we must…determine whether the disparate effect of which respondents complain is the sort of disparate impact that federal law might recognize” (unanimous majority). [7] Of course, there are limits to just how much leniency the government should provide. It is important to consider the feasibility of any proposed reform since it may stall other accomplishments of already overwhelmed bureaucratic agencies. However, the benefits of a case-by-case approach will outweigh potential difficulties.

If maintaining coverage depends on a caregiver repeatedly overcoming barriers in the state’s procedure, the agency’s methods of administration deserve scrutiny. By neglecting modifications for caregivers who struggle to navigate the system, state agencies inadvertently discriminate against beneficiaries who depend on others to file their paperwork for them.  The ADA’s commitment to nondiscrimination already emphasizes that administrative obstacles should not unnecessarily interrupt coverage for eligible beneficiaries due to their disabilities, but they must put this commitment into practice. Building on Alexander v. Choate’s recognition of meaningful access, and the critical role caregiver success plays in their dependent’s access to benefits, standards of nondiscrimination under the ADA should be expanded beyond their current limits. Whether through reform of existing procedures or increased opportunities for reasonable process modifications, states should explicitly account for beneficiaries who rely on parents, guardians, or other authorized representatives to navigate renewal requirements and procedural paperwork. Recognizing caregiver-mediated access as an essential part of Medicaid administration would better align current state practices with the ADA’s commitment to nondiscrimination. 


Edited by Margalit Salkin

Endnotes

[1] Roberts, Eric T, and Craig Evan Pollack. “Does Churning in Medicaid Affect Health Care Use?” Medical care, May 2016. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5548183/. 

[2] Medicaid, “ARCHIVED: Unwinding and Returning to Regular Operations after COVID-19,” accessed 11/2/2026, https://www.medicaid.gov/resources-for-states/coronavirus-disease-2019-covid-19/archived-unwinding-and-returning-regular-operations-after-covid-19. 

[3] Medicaid, “Medicaid, CHIP, and Marketplace Enrollments: Enrollment Trends Update,” 12/18/2023, https://www.medicaid.gov/resources-for-states/downloads/medicaid-unwinding-enroll-trends-snapshot-sep2023.pdf.  

[4]  Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (“ADA”), 42 U.S.C. § 12132, https://www.ada.gov/law-and-regs/ada/. 

[5]  “Periodic Renewal of Medicaid Eligibility,” 42 C.F.R. § 435.916 (2026), https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-435/subpart-J/subject-group-ECFR0717d3fdf4a090c/section-435.916.  

[6] “General Prohibitions Against Discrimination,” 28 C.F.R. § 35.130(b)(7) (2026), https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-28/chapter-I/part-35/subpart-B/section-35.130. 

[7] Alexander v. Choate, 469 U.S. 287 (1985), https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/469/287/. 

Previous
Previous

In Conversation with Attorney General J.B. McCuskey: West Virginia v. B.P.J. and What Comes Next

Next
Next

The Blurred Boundaries of School Zones