In Conversation with Attorney General J.B. McCuskey: West Virginia v. B.P.J. and What Comes Next

On April 28th, 2021, The Save Women’s Sports Act was signed into law by then West Virginia Governor Jim Justice. Authored by Delegates Burkhammer, J. Jeffries, Worrell, Pinson, Hanna, and Clark, the act mandates that all public schools and collegiate sports teams in West Virginia be designated based on biological sex. It also prohibits individuals who were assigned male at birth from competing on female sports teams.

Prior to the passage of the Save Women’s Sports Act, public schools and collegiate sports teams were already separated by sex; however, through a provision created by the West Virginia Secondary Schools Athletic Commission (WVSSAC), transgender athletes could compete on a sports team consistent with their gender identity, provided that their home schools also allowed it. [1] After the Save Women’s Sports Act was passed, this was no longer a reality for transgender student-athletes in the state of West Virginia. Namely, it was the new reality for Becky Pepper-Jackson, the singular openly transgender student-athlete in West Virginia. [2]

For Becky Pepper-Jackson, or B.P.J., who transitioned in third grade,  the Save Women’s Sports Act prevented her from continuing to compete on Bridgeport High School’s Girl’s Cross Country and Track and Field Teams. Soon after the Save Women’s Sports Act was enacted, B.P.J., through her mother, Heather Jackson, sued the West Virginia State Board of Education, WVSSAC, and other state and county officials, claiming that the law violated the Equal Protection Clause and Title IX. 

Initially, West Virginia intervened to defend the Save Women’s Sport Act, with a district court granting B.P.J. with a preliminary injunction that allowed her to continue playing on Bridgeport High School’s girl’s sports teams. However, the district court would soon reverse course and uphold the law, stating that its “classification on the basis of ‘biological sex’ was substantially related to the important government interest in ensuring fairness and opportunity in girls’ athletics.” [3] Upon appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit reversed in part, vacated in part, and remanded, eventually ruling in favor of B.P.J. [4]

This ruling would not last forever. On July 11th, 2024, days after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit sided with B.P.J., a petition was filed that would escalate the lawsuit to the Supreme Court of the United States. Nineteen days later and over six years after the Save Women’s Sports Act was initially passed, the Supreme Court ruled in a 9-0 decision that West Virginia’s Save Women’s Sport Act did not violate Title IX and in a 6-3 decision that it did not violate the Equal Protection Clause.

Attorney General J.B. McCuskey, who represented West Virginia’s legal interests in its defense of the Save Women’s Sports Act, called the rulings a monumental victory for female athletes in West Virginia and the U.S. broadly. [5]  In an interview I had with McCuskey, he admitted he was a bit shocked that the Supreme Court had issued a 6-3 ruling regarding the Equal Protection Clause, and that he predicted a 9-0 decision on both Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause. 

In an opinion by Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson, they stated that the majority in the Equal Protection Clause ruling did not properly adjudicate whether or not transgender girls who have undergone gender-affirming treatment retain, and therefore not experienced male puberty, had any athlete advantage. [6] McCuskey disagreed with the Justices’ opinion. He stated in our interview that although he thought the justices were good,, he also said that it should be common sense for states to reserve the right to separate sports teams by biological sex alone.

McCuskey also shared what he thought would happen in the wake of the Supreme Court’s ruling. In a news conference after the decision, McCuskey had said that, “The Supreme Court is showing a pathway forward for this to be the law of the land. That’s going to require some real courage from our congressional leaders.” [7] In conversation, McCuskey clarified that this “real courage” would require lawmakers to uphold the precedent and weigh facts more heavily as opposed to their feelings, something he noted was incredibly hard to do given the nature of West Virginiav. B.P.J.

Weighing the facts will inevitably become harder for lawmakers as they navigate a political climate divided on how to handle legislation focused on transgender individuals. In the West Virginia State Legislature’s most recent regular session alone, at least twenty bills about transgender people and gender identity were introduced, ranging from the prohibition of woke and anti-women words by the state government to a plethora of bathroom and healthcare laws. One bill, House Bill 4079, proudly states that, “In official government documents, websites, literature and in person [...] exclusionary and sexist terms shall be replaced with accurate, female-affirming alternatives.” [8]

Out of the twenty bills, eighteen failed. Two, including SB1083, which revolves around indecent exposure in locker rooms, and SB590, which places restrictions on adult cabaret performances, were passed by the Senate and received by the House of Delegates. Both failed to be passed prior to the 2026 regular legislative session being adjourned. [8]

While the majority of the bills failed, the high volume of anti-trans bills in such a short period of time highlights how contentious debates on the status of transgender individuals are becoming for the state. Likewise, general sentiments about West Virginia V. B.P.J. were extremely divisive; data from the National Women’s Law Center highlights that 55% of voters believe that local governing bodies in states should be the deciders of the athletic eligibility for transgender students, while 44% think that states with laws allowing transgender athletes to compete on sports teams should be allowed to implement those policies. [9]

Aubrey Sparks, legal director of ACLU West Virginia noted that the case was incredibly controversial and emotionally charged because of its focus on a single student who participated in sports, rather than a broader group of students. “I think one of the things that was really hard about this case and the way that it played out was the fact that it wasn’t about, you know, a group of 30 kids,” Sparks said. [10]

McCuskey echoed how difficult the case was given its nature. “Not only are you trying to handle the facts of the case, but you’re also dealing with the human aspect of it. And that’s always hard, especially when you’re dealing with a case like West Virginia V. B.P.J.,” he said. 

The ruling in West Virginia v. B.P.J. was impactful because of its implications for transgender athletes in West Virginia and across the United States. While the June 2026 ruling may have set a precedent that states can reserve the right to ban transgender athletes from competing in female sports, it failed to clarify whether Title IX and the Constitution gave states and sports teams the ability to allow transgender girls to play on female teams that aligned with their gender identity. [11] With recent lawsuits from the Trump Administration and an October 2026 emergency filing in K.M.K. v. Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, the question at the center of this new legal push is whether Title IX can permit or prohibit transgender girls from participating on female sports teams, and whether states can mandate that athletic categories be restricted by biological sex.

Edited by Juliette Workman


Endnotes

[1]  “West Virginia V. B.P.J..” 2026. Americanbar.Org. 2026. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_education/publications/preview_home/west-virginia-v-bpj/. 

[2]  ACLU. 2026. “Live Coverage: West Virginia V. B.P.J. SCOTUS Arguments.” American Civil Liberties Union. January 13, 2026. https://www.aclu.org/news/lgbtq-rights/live-coverage-west-virginia-v-b-p-j-scotus-arguments. 

[3]  “West Virginia v. B.P.J.” 2025. Oyez. 2025. https://www.oyez.org/cases/2025/24-43. 

[4] Ibid.

[5]  “West Virginia Attorney General’s Office Wins at U.S. Supreme Court, Securing Monumental Victory for Fairness and Safety in Girls’ Sports.” 2026. Wv.Gov. June 30, 2026. https://ago.wv.gov/article/west-virginia-attorney-generals-office-wins-us-supreme-court-securing-monumental-victory. 

[6]  “West Virginia v. B.P.J.” 2025. Oyez. 2025. https://www.oyez.org/cases/2025/24-43. 

[7]  Young, Charles. 2026. “McCuskey Says Supreme Court Ruling Opens Door to Nationwide Ban on Transgender Athletes in Girls Sports (Preston Copy).” WV News. July 2026. https://www.wvnews.com/mccuskey-says-supreme-court-ruling-opens-door-to-nationwide-ban-on-transgender-athletes-in-girls/article_b46ede26-a14b-4d71-941b-2140997c31e5.html. 

[8]  Crouse, Kathie. 2026. Eliminate Woke, Anti-Women Words from State Government. 

[9]  “New NWLC Poll: Voters Skeptical of Stripping Rights From Transgender Student Athletes - National Women’s Law Center.” 2026. National Women’s Law Center. June 16, 2026. https://nwlc.org/press-release/new-nwlc-poll-voters-skeptical-of-stripping-rights-from-transgender-student-athletes/. 

[10]  Munson, Emmalie. 2026. “ACLU Legal Experts Express Disappointment in Light of West Virginia V. B.P.J. Ruling.” WV News. June 30, 2026. https://www.wvnews.com/news/wvnews/aclu-legal-experts-express-disappointment-in-light-of-west-virginia-v-b-p-j-ruling/article_dbf68331-db95-4e00-b534-a3b762faaeaf.html. 

[11]  Walsh, Mark. 2026. “Trump Says Title IX Excludes Trans Girls. The Supreme Court Could Weigh in Next.” Education Week. October 9, 2026. https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/trump-says-title-ix-excludes-trans-girls-the-supreme-court-could-weigh-in-next/2026/10.

Previous
Previous

The Corporate Monetization of Democracy (Copy)

Next
Next

Bridging the Gap: Caregiver-Mediated Access to Medicaid under the ADA