The Corporate Monetization of Democracy (Copy)

The Supreme Court’s decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (2010) led to an increase in corporate super PAC spending. [1] Notably, Uber and Airbnb have invested millions in the 2025 New York City primary elections, both in support of and in opposition to candidates, contingent upon the candidate’s policy platform in the corporations’ respective industries. [2] Political expenditures from the cryptocurrency industry totaled tens of millions in the 2024 and 2026 Ohio Senate elections. [3] While the Court’s ruling protects means of political expression for mass enterprises, and corporations have not always dominated recent elections, these recent political expenditures call into question whether the ruling leaves critical legal gaps—namely its incompleteness in accounting for corporations as a de facto power in the policy stage, capable of shaping public life as legal entities. 

Recent Super PAC Expenditures

Fairshake—a super PAC primarily funded by major cryptocurrency corporations Coinbase and Ripple—and its affiliates committed $30 million in the 2026 Ohio Senate election, in addition to its $40 million expenditure in 2024, opposing former Senator and Banking Committee chair Sherrod Brown. [4] In 2023, Brown proposed several financial regulations surrounding the cryptocurrency industry, including: disclosure and transparency disclaimers, consumer and investor protections, anti-fraud and money laundering provisions, risk management liabilities, and tightened supervision (through the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act) to protect banks from cryptocurrency-associated risks and investors from insider interests. [5]

In the June 2025 NYC Democratic primary, Uber’s super PAC, Uber NY PAC, spent a reported $2.4 million throughout twelve City Council races. [6] The expenditure breakdown included online advertisements and physical mailers following efforts from the City Council to enact further job protection legislation, including bills with stronger safeguards against deactivating drivers’ accounts and locking workers from the Uber app for longer than three days without just cause. [7] Uber blocked driver log-ins during low ride demand hours, thereby decreasing minimum wage payments; with New York City considering a revision to its mandate on minimum driver pay rate, Uber persisted in its campaign efforts to secure a favorable amendment. [8] 

In 2025, Airbnb funded a super PAC labeled Affordable New York, targeting Local Law 18’s restrictions on short-term rentals and backing an impending bill to expand listing permissions for property owners on Airbnb. [9] Affordable New York spent $2 million to advocate for City Council candidates and $1.3 million to oppose mayoral candidates Zohran Mamdani, Brad Lander, and Scott Stringer. [10]

Legal Developments in Corporate Electioneering Communication

Prior to Citizens United v. FEC (2010), federal law prohibited corporations from using general treasury funds to support or oppose political candidates. 52 U.S.C. § 30118, established by the Federal Election Campaign Act Amendments of 1976, prohibits corporations and labor unions from engaging in electioneering communication, as well as speech explicitly advertising the success or defeat of political candidates, through their general treasury funds. [11] Under 52 U.S.C. § 30104(f)(3)(A), electioneering communication is defined as “any broadcast, cable or satellite communication” that directly mentions federal candidates. [12] 11 CFR 100.29(a)(2)-(b)(1) clarifies that a “broadcast, cable, or satellite communication” refers to materials that are “publicly distributed,” and also limits electioneering communication to within thirty days of primary elections or within sixty days of general elections. [13] In Austin v. Michigan State Chamber of Commerce (1990), the Court ruled that the Michigan Campaign Finance Act did not violate the First and Fourteenth Amendments when prohibiting corporations from using general treasury funds for candidate advertisements. The Court upheld Michigan’s state law that allowed corporations to establish separate political funds because the law was “precisely targeted to eliminate the distortion caused by corporate spending while also allowing corporations to express their political views.” [14] Thus, combating corruption served as the basis for a First Amendment exemption. Furthermore, the Court held that the state did not violate the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause because corporations hold a unique legal status in advantaging wealth accumulation—including limited liability, perpetual existence, and financial shareholders—which is fundamentally distinct from establishing PACs that generally represent members’ views through voluntary donations, or media outlets dispatching news to educate the public. [15]

The Supreme Court would overturn Austin twenty years later in a 5-4 decision in Citizens United v. FEC. During the 2008 primaries, the conservative non-profit corporation Citizens United intended to publish a film on Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton. The corporation intended to release the film on cable programs within thirty days of the primary election. In response to an anticipated prohibition on Hillary: The Movie, it initially filed a case in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to contest the ban. In its appeal to the Supreme Court following the District Court’s denial of a preliminary injunction, Citizens United argued that application of 2 U.S.C. § 441b to forbid the film was unconstitutional. [16]

The Court ruled that § 441b’s ban on corporation expenditures in electioneering communications violated the First Amendment. The government cannot restrict speech from a corporation based on its wealthy identity. To prevent chilling effects, “political speech must prevail against laws that would suppress it, whether by design or inadvertence.” Preventing the distorting effects resulting from special legal privileges, as argued in Austin v. Michigan State Chamber of Commerce, did not constitute a compelling interest; in his opinion for the Court, Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote that the government cannot impede speech and censor particular agents to “level the playing field.” The “open marketplace of ideas,” a pillar essential to the First Amendment, ultimately places the freedom to engage, or disengage, with speech in the hands of citizens. Combating corruption is not a compelling interest because expenditure for electioneering communication is not legally equivalent to bribes. While the Court upheld its disclaimer and disclosure provisions—the former in 52 U.S.C. § 30104(f), requiring expressed responsibility for a political advertisement, and the latter in 52 U.S.C. § 30120 requiring identification of donors and expenditure—the Court ultimately ruled that independent political expenditures by corporations, unions, and nonprofits through general treasury funds are protected by the First Amendment. [17] Funding limits remain on direct contributions to candidates, parties, and coordinated campaign activities, but unlimited expenses for independent political advocacy have transformed the modern policy and electoral landscape. 

The Legal Question of Corporations as Undefined and Unregulated Powers

The $6.5 billion total PAC expenditure from January 2025 to June 2026 accentuates this critical question about the role of corporations in civic life and policymaking—from rideshare and residential services to financial networks. [18] In one respect, citizens and corporations are free to engage in political discourse. Speech expenditures facilitate political communication (for example, running advocacy ads, releasing political films, etc.), and restricting the former is treated as restricting one’s means of expression. Thus, the Court’s decision in Citizens United ensures protection for political speech. 

However, equating speech to unbounded expenditure creates a legal tension: the disproportionate role in policymaking from non-governmental agents, as seen in today’s super PACs. While extensive legal frameworks were constructed to define corporate rights and center on shareholder interest, nevertheless, “controversy has surrounded the place of the corporation in American society.” [19] Elizabeth Pollman, a professor from the University of Pennsylvania Law School, notes that historically, “purposes in corporate charters and related provisions often referred to the promotion of public welfare.” [20] By contrast, modern law fails to form a consensus on the societal costs borne by non-corporate shareholders, including a local populace or general public; that is, there is no uniform suggestion on addressing corporate impacts in political and economic spheres, and the interests corporations serve beyond agents directly listed in contractual agreements. 

This legal gap emerges in Citizens United, where the permittance of unlimited electioneering expenditure further deepens the disconnect between legislation and corporate responsibility. Other sectors of policy influence, including governmental branches, are confined by their scope of legal authority and budget appropriations; however, corporations exercise similar, or even higher degrees of, political leverage through unlimited expenditure. Whereas the Court’s ruling in Citizens United protects corporate electioneering communication, it does not sufficiently answer the implicit question of how corporations’ unbridled policy sway might pose ramifications for constituencies. 

In the words of Justice William O. Douglas, “[t]he modern super-corporations . . . wield immense, virtually unchecked, power. Some say that they are ‘private governments,’ whose decisions affect the lives of us all. The philosophy of our times . . . requires that such enterprises be held to a higher standard than that of the ‘morals of the marketplace’ which exalts a single-minded, myopic determination to maximize profits as the traditional be-all and end-all of corporate concern.” [21] The aftermath of Citizens United v. FEC highlights a contention between the discrete issue of speech and the broader implications for public interest it permeates. When corporations invest in electioneering expenditures, policy outcomes do not solely affect internal stakeholders. It is evident that corporate endeavors reach far beyond individual economic and speech activity, into elections and public policies that affect general citizens, but this friction remains to be addressed. 

Corporations as Non-Citizen Entities

Another major concern is whether corporations share the same constitutional rights as citizens. In his dissenting opinion in Citizens United, Justice John Paul Stevens drew a solid boundary between citizens as voters under “We the People” of the Constitution and corporations: “In the context of election to public office, the distinction between corporate and human speakers is significant. Although they make enormous contributions to our society, corporations are not actually members of it. They cannot vote or run for office.” [22] If corporations are indeed legally distinct from citizens, then it becomes dubious for corporations to endorse policy preferences without regard to alignment with public interest. 

Stakes in Constituent-Driven Policy

The purpose of the Citizens United decision was to protect First Amendment rights regardless of identity, but does the ruling instead undermine general public civic involvement? Given the expenditures funneled into present elections, citizens’ abilities to have a visible voice in the “marketplace of ideas” risk debilitation, catalyzing the danger of underrepresented constituencies and ineffective democracy. Recent examples of super PAC spending prove that Citizens United is incomplete in its protection of constituent-centered, deliberative electoral processes and policymaking. 

Conclusion

The unbounded influence of corporate interests and commercial motives in shaping policy and public life extends beyond cryptocurrency, Uber, and Airbnb. The outcome of Citizens United forces legislators to reconsider whether boundless corporate political expenditure finds its cogency solely in the issue of speech, or necessitates further legal safeguards for democratic policymaking.  

Edited by Maclain Conlin


Endnotes

[1] Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310 (2010).

[2] Citizens Union, “How Big Money Lost and Small Donors Won in the 2025 NYC Primary” (Citizens Union Policy Report 2025), online at https://citizensunion.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Citizens-Union-How-Big-Money-Lost-and-Small-Donors-Won-in-the-2025-NYC-Primary.pdf (visited Oct 12, 2026).   

[3] Jasper Goodman, “Crypto super PAC to spend $30 million in bid to take down Sherrod Brown” (Politico 2026), online at https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/09/21/congress/crypto-super-pac-spend-sherrod-brown-01086078 (visited Oct 2, 2026).  

[4] Ibid. 

[5] Sherrod Brown, “Crypto Crash: Why Financial Safeguards are Needed for Digital Assets,” opening statement in “Brown: Let's Regulate Crypto and Protect Consumers” (United States Senate Committee On Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs 2023), online at https://www.banking.senate.gov/newsroom/majority/brown-regulate-crypto-protect-consumers (visited Oct 2, 2026). 

[6] Lizzie Walsh et al., “PAC Spending in Council Races More Than Doubled, Fueled by Money from DoorDash, Airbnb and Uber” (The City Reporter 2025), online at https://www.thecityreporter.nyc/2025/07/02/outside-spending-city-council-2025-election/ (visited Oct 12, 2026). 

[7] Claudia Aponte, “Uber and DoorDash Accelerate Spending in Local Council Races” (The City Reporter 2025), online at https://www.thecityreporter.nyc/2025/05/29/uber-doordash-political-spending-city-council-races-shahana-hanif/ (visited November 1, 2026). 

[8] Lola Fadulu, “Uber and Lyft Found a Loophole in a Driver Pay Law. Drivers Pushed Back.” (The New York Times 2024), online at https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/13/nyregion/uber-lyft-lockouts-wages-nyc.html (visited Oct 24, 2026).

[9] N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 26-3102 (2024) (this ordinance contains Local Law 18); Walsh et al., supra note 6 (discussing impending bill to expand listing permissions). 

[10] Walsh et al., supra note 6.

[11] 52 U.S.C. § 30118 (2024).

[12] 52 U.S.C. § 30104(f)(3)(A) (2024).

[13] 11 CFR 100.29(a)(2) (2026).

[14] Austin v. Michigan State Chamber of Commerce, 494 U.S. 652, 660 (1990).

[15] Ibid, 658–659 (“State law grants corporations special advantages–such as limited liability, perpetual life, and favorable treatment of the accumulation and distribution of assets that enhance their ability to attract capital and to deploy their resources in ways that maximize the return on their shareholders' investments. These state-created advantages not only allow corporations to play a dominant role in the Nation's economy, but also permit them to use resources amassed in the economic marketplace to obtain an unfair advantage in the political marketplace.”) (internal citations omitted).  

[16] Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310 (2010). 2 U.S.C. § 441b has been reclassified as 52 U.S.C. § 30118. Office of the Law Revision Counsel, “52 U.S.C. 30118: Contributions or expenditures by national banks, corporations, or labor organizations” (Office of the Law Revision Counsel 2026), online at ​​https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-124/t52/s30118/ (visited Nov 1, 2026).

[17] Ibid.

[18] Federal Election Commission, “Statistical Summary of 18-Month Campaign Activity of the 2025-2026 Election Cycle” (Federal Election Commission 2026), online at https://www.fec.gov/updates/statistical-summary-of-18-month-campaign-activity-of-the-2025-2026-election-cycle/ (visited Oct 13, 2026). 

[19] David K. Millon, “The Ambiguous Significance of Corporate Personhood,” 2 Stan. Agora: Online J. Legal Persp. 38, 40 (2001).

[20] Elizabeth Pollman, “The History and Revival of the Corporate Purpose Clause,” 99 Tex. L. Rev. 1423, 1434 (2021). 

[21] SEC v. Medical Committee for Human Rights, 404 U.S. 403, 409–410 (1972) (Douglas, dissenting) (internal citations omitted). 

[22] Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310, 394 (2010) (Stevens, dissenting).

Next
Next

In Conversation with Attorney General J.B. McCuskey: West Virginia v. B.P.J. and What Comes Next