College admissions can be a particularly uncertain and opaque process. While students know if they get accepted or rejected by a school, the exact reasons that contributed to their admissions decision remain a mystery. Some aspects of an application that reflect personal achievement or ability, such as GPA, standardized test scores, essay quality, and extracurriculars, explicitly contribute to a student’s likelihood of admission. However, other implicit factors that are considered in the admissions process are unrelated to merit. The clearest example of this is legacy admissions, the practice of preferentially accepting the children of alumni. [1] To justify this practice, colleges claim that legacy considerations have a limited impact and benefit institutions by contributing to funding, community, and a strong alumni network. [2] On the other hand, critics claim that legacy admissions are an unfair aspect of the application process because they are “unrelated to the merits of an individual application.” [3] As such, legacy admissions raise questions about the worth of admitted students, slow down social change, and perpetuate cycles of racial and socioeconomic inequality. [3] Because of these considerations, numerous states have already enacted bans on legacy admissions. However, this practice should be banned at a national level because it is unconstitutional according to multiple Civil Rights Acts and represents the same core situation that was restricted when affirmative action was banned.
Proponents of legacy admissions argue that the process has a limited impact on college admissions because “legacy candidates must be ‘somewhat in the ballpark’ of an institution’s GPA, standardized test scores, and extracurricular distributions to be admitted.” [2] As a result, giving preference to legacy candidates simply provides an additional boost to students who would have already been strongly considered by the admissions committee. Furthermore, colleges argue that any unfairness is outweighed by the positive effects that legacy admissions have on the school. Universities are motivated to give preference to legacy applicants “because they assist in alumni fundraising efforts” and help cultivate a strong alumni network. [4, 5] On average, legacy students and their parents donate more than non-legacies after graduation, and alumni parents will donate more to the school just to increase their children’s admissions chances. [2] The increased funding that universities receive from legacies and their parents provides the school with funds that they can then use to improve resources for all students at a school-wide level. Consequently, preferential treatment for legacy applicants serves as a mechanism to augment institutional resources for the broader student body..
Despite these arguments, over 75 percent of Americans are opposed to legacy admissions and perceive them to be unfair. [2] American society is conceptualized as a meritocracy, where self-reliance, hard work, and individual talent determine who receives wealth and opportunities. [6] The practice of legacy admissions is in direct contrast to these ideals because it favors students based on their lineage rather than any personal achievements. In practice, legacy admissions also raise questions about the merit of admitted students and detract from the value of their achievement. [2] The consideration of lineage creates an evidentiary ambiguity regarding whether a student’s admission reflects their merit or their privileged background.
In addition to introducing unfair elements in the admissions process, legacy admissions have also been shown to “slow populational demographic change in student bodies by causing ‘the composition of enrollment at a college to change less quickly than the composition of otherwise qualified applicants.’” [2] By considering lineage, universities introduce an element into the admissions process that is unrelated to merit and may facilitate the acceptance of less qualified applicants. Furthermore, legacy admissions perpetuate systems of racial and socioeconomic inequality by favoring students whose families had the capabilities to attend college in the past and “were legally permitted to attend because of their race.” [1, 7] Many first-generation students are racial or ethnic minorities, and these groups are excluded from the benefits afforded by legacy admissions and disadvantaged by the prioritization of the children of alumni. [2] At Harvard, almost 70 percent of legacy admits are white, demonstrating the disproportionate impact that this practice has for certain racial groups. [2]
Because of the unfair nature of legacy considerations, many states and universities have begun implementing restrictions on legacy admissions. Between 2021 and 2024, Colorado, Virginia, and Maryland became the first three states to ban all public institutions from giving preferential treatment to legacy applicants. [3] Illinois and California quickly followed suit, but these five states remain alone in their decision to institute policy related to legacy admissions, and only two of the five states extended the restrictions to private universities in addition to public ones. [7]
In order to preserve the equity of the college admissions process, a federal policy needs to be implemented that bans the use of legacy admissions in all public and private universities. This practice is unlawful according to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 because it has a “discriminatory effect on minority college applicants” and does not facilitate any necessary purpose for the university. [4] Additionally, Congress banned “lineage as a permissible basis for discrimination” in the Civil Rights Act of 1866 when it rejected the possibility that “citizenship should be determined by family lineage.” [8] The practice of legacy admissions violates the principles upheld in both Civil Rights Acts that lineage and race can not form the basis for any institutional discrimination in the United States. Furthermore, legacy admissions are similar to the practice of affirmative action, which was recently banned in Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. 181 (2023). Affirmative action benefited minority applicants, but legacy admissions favors white students from high-income families. Both policies are unmeritocratic and introduce a factor related to one’s background, rather than their achievement, into the college admissions process. [2] Considering the ban on affirmative action due to its preferential treatment of students of certain races, legacy admissions must be restricted to the same degree, as they simply convey these benefits to students from different racial groups. [2, 9] Both practices represent a threat to the equity of college admissions, which forms the educational cornerstone of our society. Legacy admissions threaten the principles of equality and equal opportunity, violating the ideals that the American educational system was founded on.
Edited by Angela Xiong
Endnotes
[1] Evans, Brent J., & Christensen, Cody L., “The Evolving Landscape of Legacy Preference Bans in Postsecondary Admissions: Evidence and Policy Implications from Case Studies.” Education Finance and Policy 21, no. 3 (2026): 564–585, https://direct.mit.edu/edfp/article/21/3/564/134119/The-Evolving-Landscape-of-Legacy-Preference-Bans.
[2] Serrano, Emma, “Unpacking Legacy: A Moral Inquiry into College Admissions.” University Policy Office, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, May 17, 2024, https://universitypolicy.unc.edu/news/2024/05/17/unpacking-legacy-a-moral-inquiry-into-college-admissions/.
[3] “End Legacy Preferences in the Admissions Process That Perpetuate Historical Racial Inequity.” The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, September 18, 2024, https://civilrights.org/education_policy/14-end-legacy-preferences-in-the-admissions-process-that-perpetuate-historical-racial-inequity/.
[4] Ladewski, Kathryn, “Preserving a Racial Hierarchy: A Legal Analysis of the Disparate Racial Impact of Legacy Preferences in University Admissions.” Michigan Law Review, February 2010, https://michiganlawreview.org/journal/preserving-a-racial-hierarchy-a-legal-analysis-of-the-disparate-racial-impact-of-legacy-preferences-in-university-admissions/.
[5] Fink, Benjamin, “Unlacing the Golden Bootstraps: Legislating Away Legacy and Donor Preferences in College Admissions.” Boston College Law Review 66, no. 4 (April 2025), https://storage.googleapis.com/jnl-bcls-j-bclr-files/journals/1/articles/3201/6810eb433a981.pdf.
[6] Marzen, Chad, “The Conservative Case Against Legacy Preferences in College & University Admissions.” Syracuse Law Review 74 (2024): 1053–1069, https://lawreview.syr.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Marzen.pdf.
[7] Martinez, Sophie, “Legacy Admissions Bans Spread Across State Legislatures.” Academic Jobs, October 3, 2026, https://www.academicjobs.com/higher-education-news/legacy-admissions-bans-spread-across-state-legislatures-29051.
[8] Shadowen, Steve D., Sozi Pedro Tulante, & Shara L. Alpern, “No Distinctions Except Those Which Merit Originates: The Unlawfulness of Legacy Preferences in Public and Private Universities.” Santa Clara Law Review 49, no. 1 (2009): 51–138, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1299224.
[9] Williams, Brayden, “The Academic Sins of the Father: Analyzing Legacy Preferences Under the Framework of Students for Fair Admissions.” Liberty University Law Review 19, no. 1 (2024), https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1376&context=lu_law_review.