0-for-13: When Failed Fisheries Management Becomes a Legal Failure

Depleted southern flounder, struggling striped mullet, and waning weakfish—North Carolina has increasingly become defined by what its coastal waters lack: healthy, sustainable fisheries. The State currently manages thirteen fish stocks under state Fishery Management Plans, with not one exhibiting long-term viability. [1] Decades of mismanagement have now manifested as a matter of legal liability, made evident by Wake County Superior Court Judge G. Bryan Collins Jr’s decision against the State in Coastal Conservation Association of North Carolina v. North Carolina. In August of 2026, Collins concluded that North Carolina had failed to uphold its constitutional and public-trust obligations to safeguard its fisheries. [2] To be sure, determining when fisheries mismanagement becomes a legal violation is difficult because the State cannot necessarily guarantee fish abundance; fisheries may decline for many reasons beyond regulators’control. Furthermore, the implementation of stringent regulations on commercial fishermen, ostensibly backed by intensive stock assessments, often disregards the livelihoods of fishing-dependent coastal communities. Regardless of these complicating factors, unsuccessful fisheries management crosses the line into a violation of North Carolina’s duty to protect its coastal fisheries when the State fails to collect adequate data, does not manage toward long-term viability, and fails to take meaningful corrective action when evidence demonstrates that existing management is inadequate. North Carolina should better safeguard its impacted fisheries by adopting comprehensive, measurable conservation benchmarks that take scientific, community, and economic impacts into account. 

North Carolina fisheries management traces its roots to 1822, when the State adopted regulations to restrict oyster-harvesting gear. The system gradually became more consolidated, with the fish and shellfish commissions joining forces in 1915 and jurisdiction expanding to the regulation of recreational fishing by 1965. [3] The Fisheries Reform Act of 1997 significantly reformed the existing regulatory system by implementing a modern management framework designed to “protect, enhance, and better manage” North Carolina’s coastal fisheries. [4] A major feature of this reform includes Fishery Management Plans (FMPs), essentially blueprints that were intended to lay the foundation for long-term viability in recreationally and commercially significant fisheries. [5] Within this modern framework, the Marine Fisheries Commission is tasked with adopting and implementing regulations and consists of nine Governor-appointed members representing different fisheries interests. [6] In addition to this primarily regulatory authority exists the Division of Marine Fisheries, a body largely responsible for the administrative and scientific work surrounding fisheries management, which—together with the Marine Fisheries Commission—falls within the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ). [7]

Underlying this regulatory framework, however, are constitutional, public-trust, and statutory duties that outline the State’s overlapping obligations to its coastal fisheries. Article XIV, § 5 of the North Carolina Constitution specifically identifies the State’s obligation to protect its waters for the benefit of all citizens and recognizes various natural spaces as central to North Carolina’s common heritage. [8] Article I, § 38 further guarantees a constitutional right to fish. [9] In the 2022 Coastal Conservation Association v. State decision, the North Carolina Court of Appeals interpreted that right as carrying an obligation for the State to safeguard fisheries, as a right to fish is meaningless without the availability of harvestable fish. [10] The court, however, did not find that the State had failed to carry out its duties; it expressly declined to decide the ultimate merits of the lawsuit. Beyond these constitutional obligations, North Carolina law provides more specific standards for how the State must manage fisheries. NC Gen. Stat. § 113-182.1 governs Fishery Management Plans, intending to ensure long-term viability and lay the groundwork for conservation measures that will ultimately produce a sustainable harvest. [11] The statute includes concrete guidelines for combating overfishing and maintaining healthy stocks. Together, these requirements provide standards against which the reality of the State’s efforts can be evaluated. 

In 2019, a coast-wide stock assessment found that southern flounder, one of the thirteen state-managed fish stocks, was overfished and experiencing overfishing. [12] The Marine Fisheries Commission subsequently adopted a 72 percent harvest-reduction target to achieve sustainability by 2028. [13] This measure can be viewed as a belated corrective effort following years of inadequate management. Consequently, commercial and recreational fishermen alike have expressed frustration with what they view as extreme measures imposed to remedy management failures they did not create. Beyond southern flounder, far more evidence indicates that existing management measures have struggled to protect coastal fish populations. Historically, shrimp trawling has imposed substantial mortality on juvenile fish populations through bycatch. Recurring incidental captures prompted the adoption of bycatch-reduction devices in 1992, with additional measures in 2022, which have proven to not materially benefit stocks at the population level. The State’s refusal to ban the practice outright has promoted the continued destruction of stocks. [14] By 2026, whether these persistent management shortcomings amounted to more than failed policy ultimately became a question for the courts. 

On August 17, 2026, Collins reached the merits in Coastal Conservation Association of North Carolina v. State of North Carolina after a roughly six-week liability trial, finding the State liable for failing to fulfill its fisheries-protection obligations. [15] Collins utilized “long-term viability” as a measuring stick in his opinion, a standard central to state law and similarly parroted by the State’s witnesses. [16] Applying this standard revealed a stark truth: none of North Carolina’s state-managed fish stocks displayed long-term viability. Collins describes this failure as the State’s “0-for-13 track record.” [17] The Wake County Judge called upon the North Carolina Constitution and public-trust doctrine, ultimately determining that the State failed to carry out affirmative obligations. [18] The State attempted to claim that there were substantial gaps in fisheries data, but Collins posited that the gaps themselves illustrate the State’s management failures because collecting necessary data is central to managing fisheries. [19] Collins’s decision reveals that when a significant decline in fish stocks is accompanied by failures to fulfill obligations within the State’s control—including inadequate fisheries research and failure to manage long-term viability—the legal line is crossed and the State may be held liable. 

North Carolina does not necessarily need an entirely new conservation standard; § 113-182.1 already requires fisheries management toward long-term viability. [20] Rather, North Carolina should amend § 113-182.1 to establish clearer, stock-specific benchmarks for measuring long-term viability and outline required corrective measures when unseen problems persist. The State must more stringently define what long-term viability actually means, establishing realistic rebuilding targets that could be accompanied by newly adopted closures and bag limit amendments. Drawing on a federal fisheries management model, the State could learn from Annual Catch Limits and Accountability Measures, which actively combat overfishing and trigger corrective measures when limits are exceeded. [21]

North Carolina must require concrete, corrective action when existing regulations repeatedly fail to achieve established benchmarks, while substantial gaps in fisheries data must likewise trigger a management response. [22] If shrimp-trawl bycatch repeatedly inhibits the State’s ability to establish and reach conservation benchmarks, then the Marine Fisheries Commission should consider stronger geographic, seasonal, or gear restrictions. Regardless of what the State ultimately adopts, sweeping closures are rarely a sufficient and ethical solution; North Carolina must reconcile long-term environmental gains with short-term economic realities. Adopting an updated framework with scientific, economic, and community concerns in mind would make it much more difficult for persistent management failures to continue, especially without corrective action.

The significant decline in North Carolina’s thirteen state-managed fisheries creates a lose-lose situation for both commercial and recreational anglers. Beyond facing depleted stocks and diminished catches, increased regulations are likely imminent. In June 2025, North Carolina lawmakers considered a proposal that would have prohibited shrimp trawling in inshore waters and within one-half mile of the coast. [23] The legislation was met with significant opposition, including hundreds of fishermen who claimed 75 percent of North Carolina’s shrimp harvest would be impacted. [24] To put the impact into perspective, in 2023 North Carolina’s shrimping industry harvested approximately 6.5 million pounds of shrimp valued at approximately $14.1 million. [25] Sweeping restrictions can impose substantial hardship on individual fishermen as well as coastal communities reliant on commercial fishing. The impact on affected individuals’ livelihoods deserves serious consideration, but it cannot entirely eliminate the State’s obligation to preserve fisheries for long-term viability. Ideally, the outcome of all of this controversy is a system that guarantees effective conservation action while minimizing damage to economic livelihoods. 

Collins’s decision represents an important development in defining North Carolina’s legal responsibility for its fisheries. Failed fisheries management becomes a legal failure when the State fails to fulfill its affirmative obligations that accompany ensuring long-term viability. [26] Overall, this decision reveals that North Carolina cannot treat conservation obligations as merely aspirational, especially when the State is actively going “0-for-13.” Frankly, it is unacceptable that not one state-managed fish stock exhibited long-term viability.27 NC Gen. Stat. § 113-182.1 must be strengthened with clearer, measurable benchmarks and explicitly outlined actions when those benchmarks are repeatedly missed. Regulators must also work to rebuild trust with commercial fishermen and coastal communities by incorporating their perspectives into management decisions and pursuing targeted conservation measures rather than unnecessarily sweeping restrictions. Ultimately, North Carolina’s fisheries are a public resource, and preserving that resource requires more than a right to fish; it requires a state willing and competent enough to ensure there will be fish to catch. 

Edited by Manuel Gomez


Endnotes

[1] Coastal Conservation Association of North Carolina v. North Carolina, No. 20CVS012925-910, ¶ 391 (NC Super Ct, Wake County Aug 17, 2026).

[2] Ibid, ¶ 409.

[3] North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, “About Division of Marine Fisheries,” online at https://www.deq.nc.gov/about/divisions/marine-fisheries/about-division-marine-fisheries (visited September 29, 2026).

[4] Fisheries Reform Act of 1997, N.C. Sess. Laws 1997-400, title.

[5] Ibid, § 3.4 (enacting N.C. Gen. Stat. § 113-182.1(a)–(b)).

[6] North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, “Marine Fisheries Commission,” online at https://www.deq.nc.gov/about/divisions/marine-fisheries/marine-fisheries-commission (visited September 29, 2026).

[7] North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, “About Division of Marine Fisheries,” online at https://www.deq.nc.gov/about/divisions/marine-fisheries/about-division-marine-fisheries (visited September 29, 2026).

[8] NC Const Art XIV, § 5.

[9] NC Const Art I, § 38.

[10] Coastal Conservation Ass’n v. State, 285 NC App 267, 282, 878 SE2d 288, 299–300 (2022).

[11] NC Gen Stat § 113-182.1(b), (b)(3).

[12] North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries, Southern Flounder Fishery Management Plan Amendment 3 Overview 2 (May 2022).

[13] Ibid, 1–2.

[14] Coastal Conservation Association of North Carolina v. North Carolina, No. 20CVS012925-910, ¶¶ 268-270, 285 (NC Super Ct, Wake County Aug 17, 2026).

[15] Ibid, ¶¶ 407, 409.

[16] Ibid, ¶¶ 389, 393.

[17] Ibid, ¶¶ 391–392.

[18] Ibid, ¶¶ 392–394.

[19] Ibid, ¶ 407.

[20] NC Gen Stat § 113-182.1(b).

[21] National Marine Fisheries Service, “Annual Catch Limits and Accountability Measures,” Regional Fishery Management Council Training (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, October 2024), slides 4, 8–9, 20, online at https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/s3/2024-12/new-council-member-training-catch-limits-presentation-oct-2024.pdf (visited October 7, 2026).

[22] Coastal Conservation Association of North Carolina v. North Carolina, No. 20CVS012925-910, ¶ 407 (NC Super Ct, Wake County Aug 17, 2026).

[23] Mary Helen Moore, “NC Inshore Shrimp Trawling Ban Is Dead, Republicans Say. At Least for Now,” WUNC News (June 25, 2025), online at https://www.wunc.org/politics/2025-06-25/nc-inshore-shrimp-trawling-ban-dead (visited October 12, 2026).

[24] Ibid.

[25] Ibid.

[26] Coastal Conservation Association of North Carolina v. North Carolina, No. 20CVS012925-910, ¶¶ 389, 394, 409 (NC Super Ct, Wake County Aug 17, 2026).

[27] Ibid, ¶¶ 391–392. 

Previous
Previous

Controlling Quebec: A Historical Analysis of Quebecian Bijuralism

Next
Next

BEYOND THE BAN: THE STRUGGLES OF INTERNATIONAL LAW IN COMBATING ELEPHANT POACHING